Butter Chicken Mac & Cheese
If you're looking to bring a showstopper to Thanksgiving that's packed with insane flavor, trust me, my Butter Chicken Mac + Cheese is the way to go. And I'm telling you, it will go TOE to TOE with any Thanksgiving dish. The combination of making a cheese sauce and incorporating it into a butter chicken blends so perfectly. A guaranteed Thanksgiving staple and a dish everyone is going to love at the table.
I've also included a step-by-step video tutorial above so you can follow along as you cook. It'll make putting this dish together a breeze! Watch it first before you begin cooking.

Overview:
There are 4 main steps in this recipe:
- Marinate, cook, and shred your chicken.
- Make the butter chicken sauce and combine it with the shredded chicken.
- Make the cheese sauce and combine it with the butter chicken and cooked pasta.
- Assemble, layer, and bake!
It's a little labor of love, but trust me, the results will speak for themselves. Thousands of people have made it and loved it, and I'm sure you will too!
Useful Tips:
- Shred your cheese. This helps with the flavor. Don’t skip this.
- There are two sections of cheese. One for the cheese sauce and one for the layering. I've split them up in the recipe.
- I used a 9x13 deep baking dish.
- Marinate your chicken for at least 30 minutes to 1 hour. Preferably a few hours to overnight if you have the time, but 30 minutes will do and still work wonders.
- Cashew substitute: For this recipe, you can use an additional 1/2 cup of heavy cream instead.
- You can prepare the butter chicken sauce and cheese sauce the day before. When reheating the sauces on the stove, add a little bit of water or heavy cream to get them back to the right consistency.
- When making the cheese sauce, only work with very low heat or no flame when adding in the cheese. If your heat is too high, your cheese can curdle, and your sauce will turn very grainy. We want to avoid this.
- When adding cheese to the sauce, start with very small handfuls (especially if you’re a beginner) and fully melt each addition before adding more. Trust me, I've messed up more cheese sauces than I want to admit. This helps. Small amounts and no flame. Increase the handfuls as you get more comfortable. Watch the video above to see what I am talking about.
- If the cheese sauce is too thick, add in a splash of cream or milk.
- If the cheese is not melting into the sauce, you may just need a little heat. Turn the flame on at the lowest possible temperature and whisk until melted.
- Another reason your cheese might not be melting into the cheese sauce is because you've added too much cheese and not enough liquid. If you hit this stage, stop adding cheese and add a splash of water or milk to thin out the sauce and get it back to the right consistency.
Recipe
Prep: 30 min
Marinate: 30 min
Cook: 1 hr 15 min
Total: 2 hr 25 min
Yields: 10-12 servings